RATED 5.0

Aug 7, 2025·via Google

Lauri Bell

RATED 5.0

Jul 10, 2025·via Google

Gina Sapienza

"I cannot recommend Scott McCarthy highly enough! As an Illinois driver dealing with a case in Wisconsin, I was completely overwhelmed—especially after receiving bad advice from a previous attorney that left me with a plea deal that could have seriously impacted my job. I reached out to multiple attorneys for help, and one after another (including my original representation) told me it was too late and nothing could be done. Not Scott! He took the time to listen, understood the impact this had on me professionally, and immediately got to work. He personally went to court, spoke with the DA, and was able to have the case reopened and the outcome significantly improved—something everyone else told me wasn’t possible. From the start, Scott was professional, kind, responsive, and extremely knowledgeable. When he mentioned something might be done later in the week, I expected to wait several days—but he had it resolved almost immediately. For reference, I retained him on Monday and received the incredible news by Wednesday. Whether you're a Wisconsin or Illinois driver, you want Scott representing you. If you find yourself in legal trouble in or around Rock County/Milton, don't hesitate—Scott is absolutely the person you want on your side. Thank you again, Scott!"

RATED 1.0

Jun 10, 2025·via Google

Derick Roth

"I used to have a five star for this law office and Scott still deserves that. Unfortunately I hired Maggie the second time and there was zero communication I was the one who had to reach out and even when I did there still was not anything done. Not one court date happened. She wrote up a paper that took 5 mins the first time I was in the office. That was the only time we met. When I asked for a refund it cost me almost 900 for that. So I asked why and never got a response. So I’m very upset. I thought I had a law office that I could trust and always go to. I was wrong."

RATED 5.0

May 10, 2025·via Google

David Kojis

"Great Down to earth lawyers, been great to us on the top of my list"

RATED 5.0

Mar 10, 2025·via Google

Arianne Bailey

"Maggie is absolutely AMAZING! I highly recommend her for your case! She always made me feel comfortable and kept me informed of everything! I have experienced other lawyers, and I would 100X come back to Maggie over anyone else!"