Dominique Tonacchio
Google Rating
5.0(22 reviews)
- (516) 476-0724, (732) 333-8464, (732) 383-6242
- tc@tclawyers.com, tc@tclawyers.com, tc@tclawyers.com
About:
Dominique Tonacchio, Esq., is a partner with the law firm of Tonacchio, Spina and Compitello. Dominique graduated from Holy Trinity High School in New York and attended The Pennsylvania State University in State College, Pennsylvania, where she graduated with a dual Bachelor of Arts in Criminal Law and Sociology, with a minor in Women’s Studies. Dominique graduated on the Dean’s list at The Pennsylvania State University. Dominique then attended Roger Williams University School of Law, where she earned her Juris Doctorate. While at Roger Williams University School of Law, Dominique was the Executive Vice President of the Student Bar Association, as well as a member of The Honor Board. Upon graduation, Dominique passed both the New York and New Jersey bar exams. Prior to being admitted as an attorney, Dominique worked as a law clerk for a statewide firm in New Jersey. Dominique later became an attorney with this firm, as well as the office manager. Dominique was instrumental in the Appellate Division granting appeals in two separate matters. Dominique also handled a Termination of Parental Rights hearing. While at this firm, Dominique has handled a wide variety of matters, including, Criminal, Family, DCPP, Gun Permit Appeals, Appellate Division Appeals, HOA disputes, Residential Real Estate, Education cases, Nursing Board issues, Licensing issues, and Unemployment and Board of Review appeals, as well as many other matters. Dominique swiftly ascended from law clerk, to associate, to now partner of Tonacchio, Spina, and Compitello. Dominique is admitted to practice law in the State of New York, New Jersey, and US District Court. Dominique has been selected to the 2023 Super Lawyers Rising Stars list. View More ›
DVLawyers AI Summary:
At Tonacchio Compitello Law Firm, the focus is on providing comprehensive legal services in family law and criminal law, with a special emphasis on supporting individuals going through challenging times. Their family law practice is particularly geared towards helping clients navigate the complexities of divorce, child custody issues, and other family-related matters. The firm emphasizes a survivor-first approach, prioritizing the best interests of clients and their children. The tone conveyed through the website is empathetic and supportive, reflecting a trauma-informed understanding of the difficulties faced by those dealing with domestic violence or family disputes. The firm promises to be "always on your side," highlighting their commitment to offering unwavering support to clients. They strive to create a safe and welcoming environment where survivors can feel comfortable discussing their legal needs without fear of judgment or dismissal. With a 24/7 hotline and multiple office locations, Tonacchio Compitello Law Firm aims to be accessible and responsive to clients. Their attorneys are described as dedicated and skilled, particularly in handling cases that other lawyers may avoid. This could be a suitable choice for survivors seeking legal assistance, as the firm prides itself on addressing tough cases and providing personalized solutions. While they appear to be a solid option for those needing representation in family law or criminal matters, it’s crucial for survivors to feel a personal connection with their attorney. Therefore, a consultation may be beneficial to assess whether this firm aligns with individual needs and emotional comfort levels.
Jurisdiction:New Jersey (Since 2014); New York (Since 2015)
Practice Area
Criminal Law
Guides reporting, evidence, bail conditions, no-contact orders, prosecutions or defenses, and record sealing, centering survivor safety and informed participation across the criminal process.
Family Law
Handles divorce, custody, parenting time, and support with DV-informed safety planning, temporary orders, safe exchanges, discovery protections, and long-term financial stability.
Fees
No Free Consultation
Education
B.A.
Reviews
RATED 4.0
Sep 25, 2025via Google
Dan Watkins
"Joseph Compitello took on a case passed over to him from another attorney who quit on the same client I was suing. As an adversary attorney Joe was pretty decent, I liked him even though I was suing his client.. until a procedural error occurred and I shared some information about how his client Canka Stables and Farms LLC Principal was a liar, a cheat and a fraud. He tried to verify the information I gave him with his client who hadn’t paid him or the last 3 attorneys this client had to no avail the client refused to pay him or talk to him .. but he stuck with this client anyway until the client’s fathers lawyer committed fraud on the court and tried to blame Joe for not doing his job one of the shittiest things I’ve ever seen a lawyer do to another lawyer. This forced Joe to withdraw with honor and integrity so for that I give Mr. Compitello ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️"
RATED 3.0
Sep 25, 2025via Google
Lima
"The lawyers here, specifically Amber Delaney, is very good at what she does and I’m grateful for her advocating on my behalf in court and getting good results. I’ve spoken to a partner before too and know they are passionate about what they do so I trust this firm. If it was just rating attorneys and it was easier to contact them, I would give 5 stars but I went back to them to try to get an amendment or motion filed for continued issues I’m having. This time around I’m sad to see the administrative side be so disappointing that they don’t get back to me for weeks, no response to emails, calls, can’t get an appointment with my attorney for weeks and I feel as though they are too busy and shouldn’t have taken on my case. I’m out of state in a different time zone which I’ve made clear from the beginning and a DoD contractor with no phones allowed most of the time so calling on their time is hard for me and their admin won’t answer my emails or get me in touch with my lawyer. The office admin failed to notify me when my lawyer gets pulled into court during appointment times too so not ideal for busy professionals who value their time. I’m currently searching for another Attorney after wasting so much time and money. If you go with them for expertise I would ask for attorney availabilities before paying to get an idea of how busy they are and know the only way to get in touch is through an admin operated email or office call and keep bugging them, no direct access to attorneys"
RATED 1.0
Sep 18, 2025via Google
Dan K
"Jef henninger is just not a very nice attorney. Look elsewhere."
RATED 5.0
Sep 2, 2025via Google
Tara R.
"Joe C. recently represented me in buying my condo. It was an extremely stressful time between the purchasers experiencing delays in obtaining their mortgage and an old judgment on my property that was paid off but never removed from the official records. When the purchasers tried to obtain last minute credits at their final walk-through, Joe completely dropped the hammer and called them out on their BS. We closed that afternoon. It was a true pleasure to see the buyer's attorney with his tail between his legs at the closing table!"
RATED 5.0
Sep 2, 2025via Google
Renato Meira
"I recently had the privilege of working with Dominique Tonacchio, Esq., and I couldn't be more impressed. From the moment I reached out, she was attentive, empathetic, and genuinely committed to representing my best interests. She demonstrated exceptional professionalism and legal expertise throughout the entire process. Not only did she thoroughly explain complex legal matters in a clear, relatable way, but she also fought vigorously for me, leaving no stone unturned."
RATED 5.0
Sep 2, 2025via Google
Colin FitzGerald
"Joe Comptello was a lifesaver during a very stressful time. He explained every step clearly, kept me informed throughout, and ultimately won my case. I couldn’t have asked for better representation!!"
RATED 1.0
Sep 2, 2025via Google
Ava
"UPDATE: Tonacchio Compitello filed a defamation lawsuit against their previous client (me) based on this review: I wonder if these lawyers do anything. I had a terrible experience with a case where they showed up unprepared twice and tried billing me over $4000 for doing no work at all. Contact me if you want to file a class action lawsuit. My real name is Anita."
RATED 5.0
Sep 2, 2025via Google
Gussie O'Neill
"Dominique Tonacchio is a fantastic lawyer that you can trust with your case. She gives practical advice and fights hard for her clients. I can't recommend her enough!!"
RATED 5.0
Sep 2, 2025via Google
Matthew Fleishman
"Joe Compitello is an excellent criminal defense attorney. I've recommended him to several clients and he always does a great job!"
RATED 5.0
Sep 2, 2025via Google
Aaliyah
"Hire this firm!! Bethanna is the sweetest attorney and she listens very throughly and helped ease my anxiety through my case. thank you Bethanna"
RATED 5.0
Sep 2, 2025via Google
Robert Reitsma
"Can’t say enough about Joe… Well spoken and straight to the point. When Joe got involved things moved fast and smooth. He truly made my unpleasant situation bearable. I’d recommend Joe to anyone going through family court. Thanks Joe for everything Ps We won!!!"
RATED 5.0
Sep 2, 2025via Google
Jenna Yaros
"The best law firm! Thorough, attentive, and always available when you need. My case was handled with such grace and the firm truly cares about your best interest."